Free Alternative to Adobe Firefly Generative Fill
Adobe Firefly's generative fill in Photoshop is a powerful AI tool, but it requires a Photoshop subscription ($22.99/month) and is locked into Adobe's ecosystem. bgeraser offers comparable generative fill capabilities directly in your browser: paint over any area and the AI generates contextually appropriate content to fill it. Remove objects, replace backgrounds, extend images, and create new content, all without an Adobe subscription. For users who want Firefly-style AI editing without Photoshop's cost and complexity, bgeraser delivers the key features at a fraction of the price.
Step-by-Step Instructions
Upload your image to bgeraser
Instead of opening Photoshop and navigating to generative fill, drop your image directly into bgeraser's browser-based editor. No software to install, no subscription to maintain, no Creative Cloud account required. The editor loads instantly and provides access to generative fill along with background removal, upscaling, and generative expand in one interface.
Select the generative fill tool
Switch to the generative fill tool in bgeraser's editor. This works similarly to Firefly in Photoshop: you paint over the area you want to fill and the AI generates new content. Adjust the brush size to match the area you are working on. Paint over unwanted objects, backgrounds, or areas you want to modify.
Generate AI content for the masked area
After masking the area, optionally add a text prompt to guide the AI's generation. For example, describe the sky you want, the background scene, or the type of content to fill the area. Without a prompt, the AI infers from the surrounding context. Click generate and the AI fills the masked area with realistic, contextually appropriate content.
Iterate and refine
If the first generation does not match your vision, regenerate with a different prompt or adjust the mask. You can also apply generative fill to multiple areas of the same image in sequence, building up the changes you want. Once satisfied, download the result. The workflow is faster than Firefly in Photoshop because there is no software overhead or file management.
Tips for Best Results
For best results with generative fill, use descriptive text prompts that specify what you want to see in the filled area. Instead of just saying sky, say clear blue sky with scattered white clouds. More specific prompts produce more controlled results.
Generative fill is not just for backgrounds. Use it to remove unwanted objects (power lines, trash cans, people), add elements (extend a table to fit the frame), or modify existing elements (change the color of a wall, add foliage to a garden). The AI generates any content that fits the masked area.
If you currently pay for Photoshop primarily for generative fill and background removal, switching to bgeraser saves over $275 per year. The AI quality is comparable for these specific use cases, even though Photoshop offers many other features bgeraser does not replicate.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does bgeraser's generative fill compare to Adobe Firefly?
Both tools use AI to generate content for masked image areas. Adobe Firefly benefits from Adobe's massive training data and deep Photoshop integration. bgeraser's generative fill produces comparable results for common use cases (background replacement, object removal, image extension) at a fraction of the cost. For basic generative fill tasks, most users will find the quality difference minimal.
Do I need a text prompt for generative fill?
No, prompts are optional. Without a prompt, the AI analyzes the surrounding image context and generates content that matches. Prompts are useful when you want specific content (a sunset sky, a marble texture, a grassy field) rather than leaving the decision to the AI. For object removal and background reconstruction, no prompt is typically needed.
Can I use generative fill to extend images like Firefly?
Yes, but bgeraser also has a dedicated generative expand tool that is specifically optimized for extending image borders. While generative fill can extend images by masking edge areas, generative expand provides a more streamlined workflow for the specific task of adding content beyond image borders. Both are included in bgeraser.
Is bgeraser's generative fill free?
bgeraser provides 15 free credits per month. Generative fill uses 1 credit per generation. Paid plans start at $9/month for 200 credits. Compared to Photoshop's $22.99/month (which includes Firefly credits that may run out), bgeraser is significantly more affordable for users who primarily need generative fill and background removal.
Can I do everything in bgeraser that I do with Firefly in Photoshop?
bgeraser covers the core generative fill use cases: background replacement, object removal, image extension, and content generation. Photoshop with Firefly offers additional capabilities like generative fill within complex layer compositions, advanced masking with selection tools, and integration with Photoshop's full feature set. For standalone generative fill tasks, bgeraser is a capable and much more affordable alternative.
Related Tools
Try these bgeraser tools for this workflow.
Ready to Try It?
Drop an image below to get started. No signup required for your first images. 15 free credits every month.